Setting: The time, Spring 1931; Place – Fargo, North Dakota.
Vylette closed the door to Billy’s and Steven’s room quietly and turned to go downstairs. She had tucked the boys in bed after prayers and a short story. They were her older sister, Wilma’s, two sons aged nine and seven. There were two little girls in the family too. Olive, age three and baby, Eve, age one. Wilma had put them to bed earlier.
Vylette lived with Wilma, her sister’s husband, Harry, and their four children in Fargo, North Dakota about seventy-five miles from the family farm near Wolf Lake, Minnesota. At the farm she was the third youngest of ten children, many of whom were grown and left to start lives of their own. Her parents wanted her to go to high school in the city instead of the small country school. She was super smart, a straight A student, and showed promise as a distance runner. They believed she would have more advantages at the larger school.
Vylette was fourteen, a freshman in high school. She helped Wilma around the house and babysat the kids when she wasn’t at school or attending school events.
At dinner that night, Vylette asked Harry if she could have 50₵ to enter a cross-country race sponsored by the county. There was a prize of $5.00 for the winner, $3.00 for second place, and $1.00 for third. She loved running and would challenge the wind. She knew she could win.
Harry’s face went hard and sour at her request. He said they would talk later. She thought maybe she could talk him into it by offering to do extra work around the house and by splitting the winnings with him. He had not been very welcoming when she moved in with them last August, but she did her best to please him and make him see how helpful she was.
Vylette heard voices from the kitchen as she soundlessly descended the stairs. Harsh words from Harry were indistinct but definitely angry. She tiptoed to the doorway of the kitchen and stood out of view to listen.
“I want your bastard daughter out of the house by the end of school term. Three weeks. I’m not raising another man’s kid. She can go back to the farm or go live with one of your sisters.”
“But Harry,” Wilma pleaded. “She is a help to me. I haven’t been able to be a mother to her since she was a baby. We were married when she only four and I left the farm. Can’t she please stay with us through high school?”
“Fifty cents now for a race, school clothes, schoolbooks, and on and on. You need to take care of our kids. I’m not spending my hard-earned money on a bastard.”
Blood drained from Vylette’s face. Her knees were jelly. Tears streamed unbidden from her eyes. Bastard? She knew what that ugly word meant. Was she her sister’s illegitimate daughter? Her sister – her mother? Who was she? Why was this damning secret kept from her? She ran back upstairs to her small room, her breath coming in uneven gulps. She shut the door loudly; loudly enough, she hoped it would make her sister come upstairs. She couldn’t face Harry.
A few minutes later, Wilma opened the door. Vylette’s red, tear-stained face told the story.
“You heard,” Wilma said flatly. “I’m sorry this was the way you found out. I was going to tell you when you were older.”
Vylette wanted an embrace, to be held as she stood trembling in the middle of the room. Wilma offered no such comfort.
“You have to go back to the farm after this year at school. Harry is adamant.”
“I won’t go back to the farm.”
“You’re too young to be on your own. Would you go out west to live with Tyne in Montana?”
“Anything to get far away from here.”
Tyne was one of Wilma’s sisters. Vylette thought of her as a sister, too, but realized she was her aunt. Tyne owned a boardinghouse in Butte that housed men who worked at the copper mines.
“I’ll write her and ask if that would be okay. In the meantime, don’t cross Harry or he’ll send you back to the farm right away.”
“Don’t worry. I’ll eat by myself in my room and leave any room that he comes into. I hate him,” Vylette hissed. “I hate you too and what you did to me.”
“Vylette, you don’t know the whole story. I’ll tell you more when you have calmed down.”
“I don’t want to hear. Just leave me alone. Only three weeks and I’ll be out of here no matter what I have to do. Does Tyne know what you did? Do Mom and Dad know? Oh no, I guess they are my grandparents. Does the whole world know?”
“Of course, the family knows because I was your age, fourteen, when it happened. They accepted you and love you. You are part of the family, no different than any of us. Very few others knew and most of them moved out of town. It is a closely held secret.”
“But I am different. I’m a bastard. A nobody. I shouldn’t be born.” The words felt like rocks being vomited from her gut.
In June, Vylette went by train to Butte to live with her aunt, Tyne, until she graduated from high school. She worked in the boarding house and met the man she married while still in her teens, a copper miner who loved her and provided a good life for their family. The secret of her birth was never discussed again in or outside the family. It only became known to her children after they were adults, and Tyne divulged the part of the story that she knew to one of them. Unfortunately, the issue of mistrust was a big part of Vylette’s personality. She had a hard time being close to anyone, even her own children.

Afterword:
In today’s world, children born out of wedlock are common and children do not carry the burden of public scorn. Two out of five United States’ births in 2022 were to unwed mothers. That was not the case in the early decades of the 20th century. At that time, pregnancies out of wedlock were scandalous and covered up. Now there are government programs designed to help the women who choose to birth children outside the sanctions of marriage. Although not ideal in the realm of childrearing, single parenting has been normalized. The mark of illegitimacy is not carved into a child’s personality in the way it was one hundred years ago.
This story is fiction but is based on rumors in our family. Vylette was born in 1917 in a small town in western Minnesota. She was part of a large farm family. What was not known to Vylette was that sister was actually her mother. Wilma had been “interfered with” when she was fourteen and become pregnant. Ashamed, she kept the secret of the man’s identity to her grave. The family surmised it was a neighboring farmer, a middle-aged man with a wife and children. That man was confronted by Wilma’s brothers, and he quickly left the area with his family. Vylette’s family became the owners of that neighbor’s property.
Vylette grew up believing her aunts and uncles were her sisters and brothers. It wasn’t until later she discovered in a vulgar way that she was illegitimate. Traumatized by the disclosure, Vylette’s life was forever colored by feelings of shame and degradation. Trust was destroyed. How could she trust anything if she couldn’t trust those closest to her? Those feelings permeated her personality and affected all her relationships for the remainder of her life. She kept a cold shield between herself and others, never having friends, and keeping her children at a distance. Childhood trauma leaves hidden but indelible marks on a person’s psyche and personality.
The problem with secrets is that facts buried in the story, like a body hidden in a shallow grave, can putrefy and work their way to the surface. There is space for corruption. All the people involved in this story have died. No one knew the whole truth except the two people involved. Was it rape or incest? Was the neighbor really involved; or was it a coincidence that they left town, and the family acquired the property at that time? Was that farm sold or was it payment for not reporting a crime to the authorities? Was it a boardinghouse or a brothel in Butte? Both were prevalent in the 1930s as a means for single women to earn a living. When no one speaks the truth, truth becomes conjecture and conjecture has no boundaries. The pain of a secret, like a rock thrown into a pond, sends ripples throughout many generations.





